My fourth grade students finished up a unit on volume about a month ago. This past week I gave the same group a cumulative assessment on the first two units. After grading the assessment I started to notice trends. Many students had issues with converting square units to cubic units. Students also mislabeled units related to measurement.
This is my first year using a new version of a district-adopoted math resource. This year’s scope-and-sequence had students encountering area first and then volume was discussed in a completely separate part of the unit. I believe that isolation made students think that problems in the different sections were either 1) related to area or 2) related to volume. The assessments that I graded indicated that students needed some bolstering in applying area and volume. Combining them would be a bonus.
Early this week I came across Graham’s Tweet about test questions.
I clicked on the article and found some amazing questions. I definitely geeked out after trying out a few. These types of questions made me think beyond one math skill or idea and I thought it would move students in that direction too. I decided to use the area question with my students.
You see, in the past students have been given the length, width, and height, and then asked to use a formula (often given to them) to find the volume. In this case, students were given the area and had to use that to find the side lengths. This type of task in Graham’s Tweet was definitely different problem for them.
I gave each student a copy of the sheet and had them work on it individually for about 10 minutes. Students initially thought of adding all the area sides together, but then they realized that adding them wouldn’t help in the process. I redirected students to look at what the question is asking. There were a few minutes of frusturation as students were looking for ways to find the length, width, and height.
Students were then put in groups to work out the problem. Eventually, students started to think of factors as they started to investigate numbers that work for the length. Some went the route of using a factor rainbow, while others used a trial-and-error method.
More frustration ensued, but students still moved forward. A few groups were confident that they had a solution. I briefly looked over all the responses and saw that no one had the correct answer, but I pokerfaced it and had the students work it out at home. That evening some of the students tackled the problem and came back with a solution. I was impressed with the perseverance and also how these students applied their understanding of area to find volume.
This past week students started to explore perimeter and area. I’ve observed that most students arrive into third grade with an understanding of perimeter. They can find the perimeter around polygons with a ruler or when measurements are given. When polled, the majority of students said perimeter is basically the measurement around something. After discussing perimeter, the class measured the distance around objects in the classroom. Once the class reviewed the perimeter the class moved on to area. We used scale drawings to emphasize the concept of perimeter.
On Thursday students investigated how to create a rough sketch of a floor plan.
The class used the classroom as an example. Students started by creating a rough sketch of the dimensions of the classroom. Student teams were assigned walls of the classroom to measure. After around 15 minutes students came back and wrote their measurements on the board and in their math journals. Students then transferred that rough sketch data into a scale model. This took time. We spent around 10 minutes deciding on what ¼ of an inch would represent on a grid. This was time consuming. The class had an amazing conversation on what could be an appropriate scale model that would actually fits paper. Students made the connection between a scale model and how to writer intervals on a graph. Although this was time consuming, it gave students an opportunity to use trial-and-error with different scales. Eventually the class decided on using ¼ of an inch to represent two feet in the classroom.
The class constructed the scale drawing and put in place the windows, doors and walls. The perimeter was found and then students counted the squares inside to find the area. This was a bit challenging for some as the concept of perimeter and area are different. During this process students started to identify their own misconceptions about area. Some of the squares were full while others were halves. Students had to combine the halves to find the total area. Students worked in groups to find different ways to find the area of the classroom. Besides counting the squares, students explored other strategies, such as multiplying the length and width or using some type of array model with squares.
The next day students were asked to find an object in the classroom with a rectangular face. Students found many different objects in the classroom (folder, journal, Kleenex box) while others picked objects that they couldn’t bring back to their desk (window panes, cabinet doors, desk face). Students measured the face uo the nearest inch or half-inch. They created a rough sketch and a scale drawing on grid paper. Students used the grid paper to find the perimeter and area of the item.
Next week students will be sharing their projects with the class. Each student will share their findings and the class will have a conversation about the similarities and differences between perimeter and area.